Wednesday, April 21, 2010

Media bias on abortion issue?



The distinct lack of media response to a new new opinion poll showing 70% support for the constitutional protection of the unborn and the prohibition of abortion in Ireland appears to reflect media bias in favour of abortion.

The lack of media response contrasts sharply with the enthusiastic reception given to a recent Red C poll conducted on behalf of pro-abortion agencies that made no distinction between the carrying out of necessary medical treatments in pregnancy which do not target the life of an unborn baby on the one hand and induced abortion on the other hand. See Irish Times and Irish Independent coverage of the previous pro-abortion poll.

The new poll, which was carried out between Jan. 27 and Feb. 6 2010, was conducted by Milward Brown Lansdowne on behalf of PLC. The researchers who used a quota-controlled sample of 950 people over the age of 18 asked respondents if they favor or oppose “constitutional protection for the unborn that prohibits abortion but allows the continuation of the existing practice of intervention to save a mother’s life in accordance with Irish medical ethics.”
The poll results which, were presented at a press conference in Buswell’s Hotel in Dublin on April 15th by Dr Berry Kiely, showed seventy percent support the constitutional protection while only 13 percent opposed it. Another 16 percent of respondents did not know or had no opinion.
Dr Kiely told the meeting that the poll is distinguished from other polls showing support for abortion by its distinction between necessary medical interventions in pregnancy and induced abortion
“where the life of the unborn child is directly targeted. This is a critical ethical distinction which abortion advocates constantly seek to blur,” she said.

The fact that the the main media outlets ignored the poll shows a very worrying bias, which must be challenged

Tuesday, April 20, 2010

Irish Constitution under Threat


During the Irish Labour Party annual conference last weekend Labour leader Mr Eamon Gilmore in his keynote address announced his commitment to a fundamental review of the Irish Constitution if his party becomes a coalition partner in the next Irish Government.

Mr. Gilmore is intent among other things on removing the protection currently afforded to unborn children in the Irish Constitution under article 40.3.3 . Aside from abortion, Mr. Gilmore's constitutional reform plan, according to an Irish Independent article, would also open up a host of contentious issues like the recognition of God, property rights, the definition of the family, gay marriage and the EU.
According to Mr. Gilmore
“[t]here is much about it [the Irish Constitution] that has served us well, but it is a document written in the 1930s for the 1930s”. and in the 1930s “women were considered to be second-class citizens”.


SPUC director John Smeaton in his BLOG writes
Whatever the merits or otherwise of Mr Gilmore's historical analysis, what a sad irony it is that his proposals include going much further than turning a category of Irish people into second-class citizens in 2010. If Mr Gilmore is successful, unborn Irish children will be robbed completely of citizenship, having their most fundamental right, the right to be born, cruelly taken away from them. It is highly misleading for Mr Gimore to attempt to mask a pro-abortion agenda behind the veil of equality for women. Abortion kills unborn females and harms pregnant mothers.


John Brown (brother of DANA Rosemary Scallon) in a press release asks
When will President Mc Aleese speak up to defend Ireland's Constitution? Her oath of office is quite clear, Article 12.8:"In the presence of Almighty God I do solemnly and sincerely promise that I will maintain the Constitution of Ireland and uphold its laws, that I will fulfil my duties faithfully and conscientiously in accordance with the Constitution and the law, and that I will dedicate my abilities to the service and welfare of the people of Ireland. May God direct and sustain me."

The comments by Labour party leader Eamon Gilmore, his promise to rewrite Irelands Constitution if he gets into power, clearly must draw a response from the President, as Mary Mc Aleese previously failed to speak up when Fine Gael's Enda Kenny recently said that he would abolish the Seanad completely. I for one do not believe that these party leaders represent the will of the party faithful, the vast majority of whom value our Constitution, which has served us faithfully.
Ireland's Constitution, in the democratic tradition of Europe and America, is derived, under God, from the people and in its fundamental rights articles, it guarantees the individual citizen freedom, equality and justice. Do you think America would allow the suggested destruction of their constitution - I think not, nor would President Obama sit quiet!
President Mc Aleese has held office over a period that has seen the the Irish people plunged into generations of debt with € billions of taxpayers money pledged to failing banks; cross party political corruption; a ceding of national policy, political and judicial power, citizenship and fiscal control to the EU, all contrary to our Constitution's article's 1 and 5 ; the collapse of our economy and the reintroduction of mass emigration of our young people. .
Why does the President fail to defend and maintain the people's Constitution, yet, she has no problem speaking up in supporting Turkeys application for EU membership? Does she represent the people or the politicians?
In 2004 Dana Rosemary Scallon was denied the opportunity of maintaining Article 12.2:1 of our Constitution, namely, "The President shall be elected by direct vote of the people.", when the Government and ALL political parties joined forces to re-elected their candidate - Mary Mc Aleese. I doubt that Dana would have been silent, following Enda Kenny's or Eamon Gilmore's attack on Ireland's Constitution.

Monday, April 19, 2010

UN Conference hears pro-life presentation


Lifenews.com reports that Jeanne E. Head, R.N., United Nations Representative for the National Right to Life gave an impassioned speech last week at the 43rd Session of the Commission on Population and Development (CPD) held at United Nation’s Headquarters in New York.
In her opening remarks, Ms. Head intoned the message all pro-life NGOs here at the United Nations hope to impart on the delegations of the world.
“We are dedicated to the protection of all innocent human life from conception to natural death. We see a woman’s life as a continuum deserving compassionate protections and support, beginning at her conception and proceeding throughout her entire life cycle.”

She continued by taking exception to the World Health Organizations long term claims that there has not been a significant decrease in maternal mortality since the Cairo Conference on Population and Development from 1994. Ms. Head states:
“The world has failed to reach these goals because the resources were directed toward decreasing the number of children women deliver, rather than making the delivery of their children safe, and has failed to properly direct resources to save women’s lives. I have grave concerns about the false and dangerous claims that the way to reduce maternal mortality in the developing world is to legalize abortion. I can assert without any equivocation that it is never necessary to directly attack and kill the unborn child to save the life or protect the health of the mother.”
Jeanne also underscored the fact that liberalized abortion laws do not lower maternal mortality by making strong comparisons between countries who have protective laws and those who allow abortion on demand.
“Comparison made between nations that have strong abortion restrictions, such as Ireland and Poland, and nations that permit abortion on demand, such as Russia and the United States, demonstrates that nations with strong abortion restrictions actually have lower maternal death rates than countries that permit abortion on demand.”

She reminded the delegates that previous United Nations documents have rejected abortion as a fundamental right or as a method of family planning by the International Commission on Population and Development.
“In no case should abortion be promoted as a method of family planning.”
She closed her comments by calling attention to what the women of the world truly need.
“Women in many parts of the world need clean water, nutrition, and health care for themselves and their families – not the “right” to violently destroy their children before they are born

Saturday, April 17, 2010

Lancet study on maternal mortality

According to new research data published in the Lancet the global level of maternal mortality declined substantially between 1980 and 2008. This study contradicts figures published by the UN the WHO and other UN agencies all of which have consistently reported that there has been little or no change in the numbers of maternal deaths over the period.

The study, Maternal mortality for 181 countries, 1980—2008: a systematic analysis of progress towards Millennium Development Goal 5 prepared by Christopher Murray and colleagues at the University of Washington in Seattle was funded by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.

The study assessed 181 countries and used a combination of vital registration data including surveys, census data and autopsies to rank maternal deaths, which were classified as either early and late. Early deaths were defined as the death of women during pregnancy or childbirth or in the 42 days after delivery. Late maternal deaths were defined as being between 42 days and 1 year. The researchers estimate that the total number of maternal deaths dropped from around 526300 in 1980 to a level of approximately 342900 in 2008, a reduction of 35 percent over the period. The study additionally shows that 60,000 of the 2008 deaths related to AIDS rather than any maternity related factors. The researchers found improvements in many countries including China, Egypt and Ecuador.

The Study however also shows some surprising results.
First it is clear that decline shown by the study in maternal mortality would have been even greater but for inclusion of the HIV related deaths.

Second it shows that Italy not Ireland has the lowest maternal mortality in the world at 4 per 100,000 followed closely by Australia at 5 per 100,000 and with Austria, Ireland and Israel in joint third position at 6 per 100,000.

Thirdly it shows that in some first world countries maternal mortality has actually increased. The U.S. ratio for example rose to 17 per 100,000 in 2008 from 12 per 100,000 in 1980 and represents an increase of 42 percent on the 1980 figures. Looked at another way this shows that women giving birth in the United States die at more than four times the rate of those in Italy and more than double that of Britain at 8 per 100,000 which has remained virtually unchanged in the past 20 years. Some increases in the ratios were also noted in Canada, Norway, Austria, Denmark and Singapore.

Pro-abortion groups did their utmost during the negotiation of the millennium development goals MDG's to include a goal on reproductive health in order to prioritise abortion and access new funding sources. Despite their best efforts however their plans were defeated, pro-life efforts succeeded in ensuring that Development Goal 5 focused specifically on the reduction of maternal mortality only to the exclusion of the abortion agenda. The pro-abortion response to this has been their determination to find ways of including their pro-abortion agenda in MDG 5 and the main plank of of their strategy was the claim that maternal mortality levels were virtually static. The new survey is therefore unwelcome news for them as they prepare for a women deliver conference in Washington in June and the MDG review in September.

The New York Times in an article quote Dr. Richard Horton of the Lancet, who states he received pressure from maternal mortality advocacy groups not to release the new findings at this time.“I think this is one of those instances when science and advocacy can conflict,” he said.

Dr. Horton according to the article said the advocates, whom he declined to name, wanted the new information held and released only after certain meetings about maternal and child health had already taken place.

He said the meetings included one at the United Nations this week, and another to be held in Washington in June, where advocates hope to win support for more foreign aid for maternal health from Secretary of State Hillary Rodham Clinton. Other meetings of concern to the advocates are the Pacific Health Summit in June, and the United Nations General Assembly meeting in December.

“People who have spent many years committed to the issue of maternal health were understandably worried that these figures could divert attention from an issue that they care passionately about,” Dr. Horton said. “But my feeling is that they are misguided in their view that this would be damaging. My view is that actually these numbers help their cause, not hinder it.”

Friday, April 16, 2010

Medical Council attack on Catholic Conscientious objection


We report today on the case of Dr. Phil Boyle, who runs a fertility treatment practice in the Galway clinic. Dr Boyle is the foremost practitioner in Ireland in the use of NaproTechnology, a Catholic approach to treatment of infertility. Last year Dr Boyle declined to treat an unmarried couple on the basis that he limits such elective treatment to married couples only, in accordance with Catholic principles.

Following a complaint by the couple to the Medical Council Dr Boyle was summoned to appear before the Fitness to Practice Committee last week on a professional misconduct charge.

Dr Boyle was acquitted on a technicality but his right to conscientious objection was not recognised. He had been charged with refusing to treat a patient and of not referring the patient to another doctor. The Fitness to practice Committee ultimately accepted that the couple had not become his patient and that in the circumstances referral to another doctor did not arise.

The fact that this case was not dismissed on the basis of the conscientious objection of Dr Boyle is a cause for concern

It also appears that this may not be the end of the matter, it is understood that the couple may now take their case to the Equality Authority on the grounds that Dr Boyle is in breach of the Equal Status Act which outlaws ‘discrimination’ in the provision of goods and services on the grounds of marital status.

We will watch carefully how the issue progresses as it could have major implications for the conscientious objection of medical practitioners in all areas of practice

see also report on the issue by the Iona Institute