Friday, November 19, 2010

HEALTHCARE CANNOT DIVORCE ITSELF FROM MORAL RULES


Vatican Information Services for Thursday November 18th report that Pope Benedict XVI sent a Message to Archbishop Zygmunt Zimowski, president of the Pontifical Council for Health Pastoral Care, and to participants in the council's twenty-fifth international conference which is currently being held on the theme: "Towards egalitarian and human healthcare in the light of 'Caritas in veritate'".

In his Message Pope Benedict highlights
"the need to work with greater commitment at all levels in order for the right to healthcare to be effective, facilitating access to primary medical assistance. In our own time", he continues, "we are witnessing, on the one hand, a care for health which risks turning into pharmacological, medical and surgical consumerism, almost a cult of the body while, on the other hand, we see the difficulties millions of people face as they seek to obtain minimal subsistence and the medicines they need to cure themselves".
After highlighting the importance of "establishing true distributive justice which guarantees everyone adequate care on the basis of objective needs", the Pope insists that "the world of healthcare cannot divorce itself from moral rules, which must govern it in order to ensure it does not become inhuman" Pope Benedict continued.

"Justice is promoted when we welcome the life of others and take responsibility for them, answering their expectations because in them we see the face of the Son of God, Who became man for us. The divine image impressed in the features of our brothers and sisters is the basis of the exalted dignity of each individual and arouses in each of us the duty to respect, care and serve"
.The Holy Father then clarified the issues by highlighting the plight of the unborn in the context of the international preoccupation with reproductive health and artificial procreation techniques and in highlighting the importance of defence of life from conception to natural death.
"healthcare justice must be one of the priorities on the agendas of governments and international institutions. Unfortunately, along with positive and encouraging results, opinions and schools of thought exist which harm this justice. I am thinking of questions such as those associated with so-called 'reproductive health', the use of artificial procreation techniques that involve the destruction of embryos, and legalised euthanasia. Love for justice, the defence of life from conception until natural end, must be supported and proclaimed, even if this means going against the tide. Fundamental ethical values are the shared heritage of universal morality and the basis for democratic coexistence"
the Holy Father concluded his message to the conference participants by reminding them
"Only by looking at the world with the gaze of the Creator, which is a gaze of love, will humanity learn to live on earth in peace and justice, equitably sharing the planet and its resources for the good of each man and woman. For this reason", the Pope concludes, "I would advocate the adoption of a model of development based on the centrality of the human person, on the promotion and sharing of the common good, on responsibility, on a realisation of our need for a changed lifestyle, and on prudence, the virtue which tells us what needs to be done today in view of what might happen tomorrow"
.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

Dublin's Archbishop Martin to participate in the Vigil for Life by leading Vespers in Dublin's Pro-Cathedral

We reported last month that Pope Benedict XVI will lead a "vigil for nascent life" by presiding over first vespers on Nov. 27 in St. Peter's Basilica, to mark the start of Advent.

We also reported that Pope Benedict will not be the only one leading the vigil, as the initiative is being promoted through bishops' conferences throughout the world. A letter from Cardinal Antonio Cañizares Llovera of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments and Cardinal Ennio Antonelli of the Pontifical Council for the Family has been sent to the bishops of the world to invite a similar celebration and prayer initiative on a local level throughout the Catholic Church.

We can now report that the Dublin Archdiocese has announced that Archbishop Diarmuid Martin will participate in this important event by leading vespers on Saturday 27th Nov. details of participation in the vigil as follows:
The Holy Father will celebrate in St Peter’s Basilica a solemn ‘Vigil for all nascent human life’ coinciding with the first vespers of the First Sunday of Advent. A similar celebration will take place in St. Mary’s Pro- Cathedral on Saturday 27 November at 4.00 p.m. led by Archbishop Diarmuid Martin which will be incorporated into our Annual Diocesan Advent Service. The atmosphere for these Advent celebrations is quiet and tranquil and you are invited to begin your season of prayerful preparation in this quiet oasis.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

In vitro fertilisation part of the holocaust of abortion according to Argentinian Archbishop

Archbishop Hector Aguer of La Plata, has criticized in vitro fertilization as a technique that plays with the lives and deaths of thousands and thousands of people and called it a "new holocaust that is part of the holocaust of abortion.”
On Nov. 6, during his program, “Keys to a Better World,” Archbishop Aguer referred to the awarding of the Nobel Prize in Medicine to Robert Edwards, for his efforts to conceive the first child through in vitro fertilization.
“This belated recognition again raises the issue of the judgment that must be made regarding this technique that has spread notably throughout the world,” the archbishop said.
Archbishop Aguer pointed to “the fundamental ambiguity” that the procedure presents.  “It would seem that through the manipulation of gametes, as if they were an industrial product, a human being can be manufactured.”
He went on to note that “despite being conceived under such circumstances, the human embryo is still a personal being.” He explained that "it is a well known fact that in order to achieve a birth, a number of embryos are destroyed, and it is very common that only the best ones are chosen and the others thrown away as unusable biological material.”
Archbishop Aguer also pointed out that today there are “thousands and thousands of frozen embryos all over the world” whose fate is unknown and that a multi-million dollar industry has developed from artificial fertilization.
For this reason, he continued, in seeing the Nobel Prize awarded to the creator of in vitro fertilization, we must reflect on “the importance of recognizing the fundamental truths that have to do with the dignity of human life and its sacred nature, from conception to natural death.”
“Bringing about the birth of a child at any cost to satisfy the understandable desire of a couple to have a child must not be done,” he stressed.  “This desire must be conformed to objective ethical criteria.”
Catholic teaching is opposed to IVF because the procedure is contrary to the natural order of sexuality. The technique also involves the elimination of human embryos both inside and outside the mother’s womb, which constitutes abortion in each case.

Tuesday, November 16, 2010

UN Committee debate "the right to sexual and reproductive health"

The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural  Rights (CESCR) during its 45th session (1 – 19 November 2010), held a Day of General Discussion (DGD) on the right to sexual and reproductive health in accordance with articles 12 and 10 (2) of the Covenant. according to the website the day was arranged in order to provide an opportunity to exchange views and to garner insights from practitioners and academic experts. The day of discussion was arranged as a series of four panel debates with minimal general debate. The debate themes were as follows:

  1. Definitions and elements of the right to sexual and reproductive health;
  2. Cross-cutting issues and groups in focus;
  3. Legal aspects and State obligations; and
  4. Conclusions.
Several weeks ago when I became aware of the arrangements for the session I submitted a paper to the CESCR on behalf of the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children challenging the right of the committee to draw up a new 'general comment' on the issue. I also attended the actual session  on Monday Nov. 15th and made a statement during the session.

The panel speakers were all pro abortion and it became clear during the first session that the creation of a right to abortion was one of the main underlying purposes of the whole exercise. Many of the speakers spoke of the need for access to so called "safe and legal" abortion. There was also a suggestion that for women to be able to access this so called right the issue of conscientious objection needed to be limited. The lack of balance in the panels is just another example of the blatant pro-abortion attempts to impose their anti life agenda on every country through the UN system.  This is the sort of thing that brings the UN into disrepute.

Representatives from a number of member states attended and with one exception all their interventions were pro-life.  Good Statements were made by Nicaragua, Poland, Egypt, Pakistan, Malta, Chile and Honduras. The meeting was arranged to limit the amount of debate from the floor but due to the fact that one of the panelists did not turn up there was additional time for NGO interventions. Once again while there were a small number of anti life statements the vast majority of the NGOs who spoke were pro-life and some excellent interventions were made.

Two members of "Silent no More " women who had been hurt by abortion spoke strongly against the concept of so called "safe and Legal abortion" and told the meeting that making it legal does not make it safe. It is never safe for the baby but many women suffer both physically and/or psychologically afterwards

The following is the statement I prepared but due to time constraints I had to curtail it to some extent.

(the bold text represents the parts of the statement actually made)
Mr. Chairman, my name is Patrick Buckley, I represent the Society for the Protection of Unborn Children. I have already submitted a paper on behalf of my organisation challenging the right of this committee to draw up a general comment on a term not used in the carefully crafted wording of the Convention.

We say in addition that the right to life of all human beings from the moment of conception to natural death, is protected in the bill of rights consisting of the UN Charter, the Universal declaration of Human Rights and the subsequently enacted Covenants and other legally binding Conventions.

We also say that the Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) recognizes human rights during the entire pre-natal period of life.

First the preamble of the CRC expressly says that children need rights while they are in the pre-natal period of their life-cycle and this follows on from the original 1959 Declaration on the Rights of the Child:

“the child, by reason of his physical and mental immaturity, needs special safeguards and care, including appropriate legal protection, before as well as after birth.”
  • The CRC having used the term child in its preamble in respect of a human life before as well as after birth in Article 1 defines the word child as all “human beings” who are under 18 years of age (unless the State sets a lower age limit).
  • The right to health, in Article 24 is for the benefit of the child who is the rights holder under the convention and expressly gives children rights during the entire pre-natal period.
  • When Article 1 is read in the light of Article 24, “human being” covers children during the entire pre-natal period, that is to say, from conception onwards. Article 24 reads:
1. States Parties recognize the right of the child to the enjoyment of the highest atainable standard of health …

2. States Parties shall pursue full implementation of this right, in particular, shall take appropriate measures: …

(d) To ensure appropriate pre-natal … health care for mothers.” (Article 24; italics and underlining added.)

The child is the right-holder of the right to pre-natal care, not the mother, according to the text of Article 24:  States Parties recognize the right of the child … to pre-natal … care.
  • The fact that the text says “pre-natal …health care for mothers” (emphasis added) does not convert the right into the right of the mother. By definition, pre-natal care is medical care that is delivered to the mother’s body. The care to the child is delivered through actions directed at the mother’s body.

    In other words, the child has the right to have health care given to his or her mother, for the purpose of ensuring the child’s well-being.
We also say that it is the duty of this committee to implement this Convention in accordance with the terms of the Vienna Convention on the Law of Treaties, which sets out interpretive norms for all treaties.

Article 31 of the VCLT says:  "A treaty shall be interpreted in good faith in accordance with the ordinary meaning to be given to the terms of the treaty in their context and in light of its object and purpose."
In other words, attention must be paid to the actual text of the treaty and, as an aid to interpretation, to its surrounding context.

We say that there is no such right as a right to abortion, no right to take innocent human life and there never can be such a right. We also call on this Committee to reject pressure from powerful international organizations, which derive huge financial benefit from the taking of human life.

Finally we reiterate that this committee is not empowered to reinterpret the terms of the Convention and we further assert that there is no room for ideological crusades on the part of the Committee in attempting to expand the scope of the convention whilst ignoring the plight of the most vulnerable human beings, babies once conceived and awaiting birth.
Whilst it was clear that the panelists and the committee members were taken aback by the number of pro-life interventions from both member states and the NGO sector, it was also clear that they are determined to proceed with their stated objective of preparing a general comment on the so called "right to sexual and reproductive health"

Monday, November 15, 2010

Post abortion trauma and the need for help


It is constantly being brought home to us that  – besides the obvious result that a baby, an unborn human being, is killed in the process – abortion hurts, damages and affects so many people, particularly the mother.   Members of organisations such as ‘Silent No More’ – made up of women who have had an abortion – are bravely speaking out in public about their experiences.     

‘What I’m really thinking’ is the title of a short piece in the Guardian newspaper’s ‘Weekend Magazine’ (13 October 2010), and it is a very chilling reminder to all of us of the torment that a mother contemplating abortion goes through.
It tells the sad story of a young girl.  ‘There isn’t a choice’, she says, ‘I am an unemployed recent graduate barely able to afford the pregnancy test, with a boyfriend on bar wages.  But after the scan, I want the nurse to find some unfathomable medical reason why termination isn’t an option, so I’d be justified in keeping a child I don’t want to lose but can’t really provide for.’  Following the abortion of her child, she says: ‘Hopefully soon I can focus on a career and creating the right circumstances eventually to have a child.  But the due date for this baby is seared into my mind now.  I won’t ever be able to forget it.’ [Emphasis added]

There are wonderful agencies in nearly every country now that offer the help and practical assistance that was so obviously needed by this young woman.   The tragedy is that the services provided by agencies such as, for instance, the Cardinal Winning Initiative and the Sisters of the Gospel of Life in Scotland; Rachel’s Vineyard; ARCH (Abortion, Recovery, Care and Helpline), in the UK, to name but some of them, are often over-stretched, and indeed their existence is sometimes unknown by those who need them most.