Friday, March 19, 2010

Childbirth past and present

For quite some time now there has been a controversy about the medical procedure called symphysiotomy which was performed in a number of maternity hospitals – usually Catholic - in Ireland some decades ago. This involved the widening of the pelvis so that the passage of the baby into this world was made easier for the mother and, presumably, for the baby. Horror stories abound about the subsequent pain and disability in later life that often followed the procedure. The general attitude and response to the accounts of suffering by women who underwent the procedure was, and still is, one of utmost anger and disbelief that a mother could be subjected to such a barbaric practice.
A recent letter in the Irish Times, however, gives another interesting (and frightening) side to the story:

‘Symphysiotomy may appear now as a horror weapon of the past, but it actually saved the lives of many babies.
‘I trained as a midwife in the Rotunda [one of the main maternity hospitals in Dublin, not under Catholic management] around 1956-58. We had lectures on the history of obstetrics but symphysiotomy was not performed there at that period or ever. Rather, what happened there, prior to successful Caesarean sections, was perforation of the skull of the infant and death of the infant to save the mother.
‘Do not forget, when C-sections first became a way of dealing with difficult births, it was rarely chosen, as the mother usually haemorrhaged to death.
‘Why? Because those who operated were not aware that the uterus had to be sutured prior to the closing of the abdominal gap. So in the 1950-60s obstetricians performed under the dark cloud of C-sections and certain death of the mother.
‘To enable mother and child to survive, symphysiotomy was the only answer. It was very rarely necessary.
‘Please see the good work and effort of the past as an advance from dark and appalling suffering misery of the pre-Famine millions in Ireland and elsewhere.
‘Yes, a few were crippled, but they were survivors. Those doctors and obstetricians gave of their best for their patients at that time, most of them have now passed on. I speak for them, may they rest in peace.’

Thursday, March 18, 2010

"Abortion is the foundational human rights issue of our lifetime"


Archbishop Charles Chaput, of Denver, Colorado, USA, was speaking recently at Houston Baptist University. The subject of the Archbishop’s talk was: The vocation of Christians in American Public Life.

In the course of his address the Archbishop said:
‘I’m here as a Catholic Christian and an American citizen – in that order. Both of these identities are important. They don’t need to conflict. They are not, however, the same thing. And they do not have the same weight. I love my country. I revere the genius of its founding documents and its public institutions. But no nation, not even the one I love, has a right to my allegiance, or my silence, in matters that belong to God or that undermine the dignity of the human persons He created. …’

He goes on mention a third point to which he referred earlier in his talk, relating to the realities we face today, and what Christians need to do about them.
[…] I listed all the urgent issues that demand our attention as believers: abortion; immigration; our obligations to the poor, the elderly and the disabled; questions of war and peace; our national confusion about sexual identity and human nature, and the attacks on marriage and family life that flow from this confusion; the growing disconnection of our science and technology from real moral reflection; the erosion of freedom of conscience in our national health-care debates; the content and quality of the schools that form our children.

‘The list is long. I believe abortion is the foundational human rights issue of our lifetime. We need to do everything we can to support women in their pregnancies and to end the legal killing of unborn children. We may want to remember that the Romans had a visceral hatred for Carthage not because Carthage was a commercial rival, or because its people had a different language and customs. The Romans hated Carthage above all because its people sacrificed their infants to Ba’al. For the Romans, who themselves were a hard people, that was a unique kind of wickedness and barbarism. As a nation, we might profitably ask ourselves whom and what we’ve really been worshipping in our 40 million “legal” abortions since 1973. […]’


Strong words – but all too necessary in today’s world. I am reminded of the words of St. Thomas More, Patron Saint of Politicians, when he said that he was ‘The King’s good servant, but God’s first.’

Wednesday, March 17, 2010

Euthanasia workshop to go ahead after all

We understand that the Euthanasia workshop on which we previously BLOGGED has not been cancelled after all. Truth TV report that he organisers have found a new venue willing to host the event and that the pro-euthanasia workshop will proceed after all.

NOTE since posting this BLOG we have learned that Buswell's Hotel management have cancelled the booking but that the organisers of the workshop are still actively seeking another alternative venue

we reprint below the Truth TV urgent post and would ask readers to contact the Buswells Hotel management asking for the cancellation of the event and to contact the Gardai as euthanasia and assisted suicide is illegal in Ireland

This is an urgent update in regard to the ‘DIY-Euthanasia Workshop’ which, we have now confirmed, will go ahead in a new venue, Buswells Hotel in Dublin, this Friday, March 19th.

See below for our previous report on this sick ‘workshop’, which is seriously objectionable on many levels. The ‘workshop’ explains to sick and elderly people how to commit suicide by taking a lethal dose of a veterinary medicine, Nembutal, which is unapproved in Ireland.

Please make your voice heard. Last week this ‘workshop’ was cancelled from a venue in Capel Street following an alert by the Life Institute. We’re now asking everyone to call Buswells Hotel on 01 6146500 and respectfully ask the manager, Paul Gallagher, to withdraw the venue for this disturbing and illegal workshop.

Assisted suicide is illegal in Ireland and we have also contacted the Garda Superintendent in the area on the matter. We’ll keep you informed.

Tuesday, March 16, 2010

Opposition to civil partnership bill

Opposition to the Irish Governments plans to introduce civil partnerships legislation is growing. In the interest of protecting the constitutional position of the family based on marriage and the protection of democratic principles it is essential for members of the public to express their views before it is too late.

Readers of my blog in Ireland may like to know that it is not too late to let their politicians know their views in relation to the measure known as the ‘Civil Partnership Bill 2009’. I have written about this obnoxious and destructive Bill on a number of occasions (17 Oct 2009, 24 October 2009, 19 December 2009, 13 March 2010).

It is reported that the Bill will shortly be placed before the Select Committee on Justice, Equality and Defence and Women’s Rights for discussion, and I understand that individual citizens may write to: Deputy Brendan Kenneally, Chairman, Joint/Select Committee on Justice, Equality, Defence and Women’s Rights, Houses of the Oireachtas, Leinster House, Kildare Street, Dublin 2, setting out (politely, of course!) their objections to the content of the Bill. It is advisable, also, to send a copy of all submissions to Mr. Alan Guidon, Clerk to the Committee, at the same address.

Monday, March 15, 2010

My life is in your hands


Fr Finigan, in his blog for 9 March 2010, brings to our attention the fact that the Spanish Conference of Bishops has launched a new campaign against the liberalisation of abortion (see my blog for 6 March 2010 about King Juan Carlos having signed a new law, which allows for a wide-ranging provision of abortion in Spain). Part of the Bishops’ campaign – which will culminate in a ‘Day for Life’ – is the provision of 13,000 billboards that will be erected in seventeen cities throughout Spain.

The billboards carry a photograph of a baby, supported on the hands of two people, and the message is: ‘Es mi vida! Esta en tus manos. Jornada por la vida, 25 Marzo’. In translation, this says: ‘My life is in your hands. Day for Life, 25 March’.

I know that many Bishops’ Conference around the world are doing great work to bring the pro-life message to their people, but wouldn’t it be just wonderful if every Bishops’ Conference were to follow the lead and example of the Spanish Bishops!